Can I Sue My Financial Advisor in New York?
Yes. In New York, you can bring a claim against a financial advisor, and usually the firm the advisor works for, if the advisor made a recommendation that was not in your best interest, misrepresented or hid risks, traded without permission, or otherwise breached a duty owed to you, and that misconduct caused your loss. Most claims against brokerage firms are decided in Financial Industry Regulatory Authority ("FINRA") arbitration rather than court, and claims against registered investment advisers ("RIAs") usually go to the arbitration forum named in the advisory agreement. Some deadlines are as short as three years, so do not wait. If you lost $100,000 or more, call (914) 304-4051 for a free consultation.
Can I sue my financial advisor just because I lost money?
No. A market loss by itself is not a claim. A claim requires misconduct, such as a bad recommendation, a misleading explanation of risk, an undisclosed conflict or trading you never approved, and a loss caused by that misconduct rather than by the market alone.
What claims can I bring?
Depending on the facts and the type of account, New York investors commonly bring claims for:
Recommendations not in your best interest. Too much risk for your age, goals or need for cash, or a strategy that did not fit your account.
Misrepresentation and omission. Being told an investment was "safe," "guaranteed" or "like a CD" when it was not, or not being told about key risks or costs. See fraud and misrepresentation.
Breach of fiduciary duty. Putting the financial advisor's or firm's interests ahead of yours. See breach of fiduciary duty.
Overconcentration. Too much of your savings in one stock, sector or product.
Unauthorized or excessive trading. Trades you did not approve, or trading that mainly generated commissions.
Failure to supervise. The firm did not catch or stop the misconduct.
Breach of contract. The firm or financial advisor did not do what the account or advisory agreement promised.
One New York-specific point: the Martin Act, New York's main securities law, is enforced by the Attorney General and does not give investors a private right to sue under it. Common-law claims like fraud, fiduciary duty and negligence remain available if their requirements are met. For more on New York remedies, see my New York investment fraud lawyer page.
Who can I sue: the financial advisor, the firm, or both?
Usually both. Firms are generally responsible for what their financial advisors do on the job, and they have their own duty to supervise. The firm is also usually the party able to pay an award.
Is my financial advisor regulated as a broker-dealer or as an investment adviser?
"Financial advisor" is a job title, not a legal category, and the answer affects which rules apply.
Broker-dealer representatives. If your account is a brokerage account (typically paid by commissions), recommendations made on or after June 30, 2020 are governed by the Securities and Exchange Commission's ("SEC") Regulation Best Interest ("Reg BI"). Reg BI requires the firm and the financial advisor to act in your best interest when making a recommendation and not to put their own interests ahead of yours. Under New York law, whether a brokerage firm also owes you a broader fiduciary duty depends on the relationship. It is generally stronger when the financial advisor had discretion over your account or you relied on them heavily.
Registered investment advisers. If you pay an advisory fee (often a percentage of assets), the RIA owes you a fiduciary duty under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 ("Advisers Act"), which covers the entire relationship.
Dual registrants. Many financial advisors are registered both ways and can wear either hat on different accounts. Which hat applied to the advice you got is often a key question.
You can check your financial advisor and firm on FINRA's BrokerCheck (brokercheck.finra.org) and the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure ("IAPD") site (adviserinfo.sec.gov). Both show registrations, employment history and many past customer complaints. Your Form CRS, a short relationship summary firms must give retail investors, also says which type of account you have.
Do I go to court or arbitration?
For most New Yorkers, the answer is arbitration.
Brokerage accounts. Almost every brokerage account agreement requires FINRA arbitration. Even without an agreement, FINRA's rules let a customer require a member firm to arbitrate. There is no jury, and appeals are very limited. FINRA has New York hearing locations in New York City, Albany, Buffalo and Syracuse, and FINRA generally picks the location closest to where you lived when the events happened.
Advisory accounts. An RIA's advisory agreement often requires private arbitration before the American Arbitration Association ("AAA") or JAMS. If there is no arbitration clause, the claim can go to court, usually New York Supreme Court, the state's general trial court.
How long do I have?
Deadlines depend on the claim and the forum. Under New York law:
Fraud: the greater of six years from the fraud or two years from when you discovered it, or reasonably could have, under Civil Practice Law and Rules ("CPLR") 213(8).
Negligence: generally three years (CPLR 214(4)).
Breach of fiduciary duty: no single deadline. A claim seeking money damages is generally three years, but six years can apply when fraud is essential to the claim or the relief is equitable.
Breach of contract: generally six years (CPLR 213(2)).
FINRA adds its own rule. Under FINRA Rule 12206, a claim generally is not eligible for FINRA arbitration once six years have passed from the event giving rise to it, and that rule does not extend any statute of limitations. If you lived outside New York when the loss happened, a shorter out-of-state deadline may apply. When a claim "accrued" is often disputed, so have your situation reviewed promptly.
What does it cost?
The consultation is free. Investor cases at my firm are handled on a contingency fee basis, with no hourly fees, and my firm is paid only if you recover. How case costs and expenses are handled depends on the case and is discussed at the consultation. FINRA charges filing and hearing fees based on the size of the claim, and AAA and JAMS fees depend on which rules apply. Contingency fee percentages vary among lawyers, which makes choosing the right lawyer even more important.
What should I do now?
Gather documents: account statements, trade confirmations, account opening forms, the advisory agreement or Form CRS, emails and texts, and any notes of conversations.
Write down what you were told about risk, costs and why each investment was recommended, while you still remember.
Check BrokerCheck and IAPD for your financial advisor and the firm.
Be careful what you sign. Do not sign a release or settlement tied to the problem before getting advice.
How I can help
I represent investors in FINRA arbitration against brokerage firms, in arbitration against RIAs and in court. I served as in-house counsel at one of the largest brokerage firms and worked at one of the largest defense law firms in the world. I have represented over 400 clients and recovered over $130mm for investors. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. I focus on investor claims involving losses of $100,000 or more. I represent investors throughout New York from my office in White Plains, and nationwide. Contact me or call (914) 304-4051 for a free consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue my financial advisor in court instead of arbitration?
Usually not, if you signed a brokerage or advisory agreement with an arbitration clause, and most investors have. Without one, court may be an option.
Is my financial advisor a fiduciary?
An RIA is a fiduciary under the Advisers Act. A brokerage firm must follow Reg BI, and under New York law may owe broader fiduciary duties depending on the relationship, such as discretionary trading.
Can I recover losses if my financial advisor has left the firm?
Often yes. Claims usually name the firm that employed the financial advisor when the misconduct happened, not just the individual.
Attorney Advertising. This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Investor cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, with no hourly fees; how case costs and expenses are handled depends on the case and the client, and is discussed at your free consultation. Daren A. Luma, PLLC, 75 South Broadway, Suite 400, White Plains, NY 10601, (914) 304-4051.
Photo: Lower Manhattan, photo by Marco Almbauer, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.




Comments